Phren bark (corrupted)
23838
Phrin remains
Item ID Unknown
Phrin remains
3398
Pickaxe handle
467
Pickaxe handle
466
Pickled brain
4199
Picture
1510
Pie dish
2314
Pie dish
2313
Pie recipe book
7163
Pie recipe book
7162
Pie shell
2316
Pie shell
2315
Piece of railing
1486
Pieces of eight (discontinued)
8951
Pigeon cage
424
Pike
352
Pile of salt
Item ID Unknown
Pile of salt
4689
Pineapple
Item ID Unknown
Pineapple chunks
2117
Pineapple chunks
2116
Pineapple pizza
2302
Pineapple punch
2049